Bulgarian Folklore

Journal of Folkloristics,

Ethnology, Anthropology and Arts

 

Institute of Ethnology and Folklore Studies

with Ethnographic Museum at BAS

Bl. 6, Acad. G. Bonchev Str.

1113 Sofia, BULGARIA

bulfolk@abv.bg

 

 

Reviewers report

 

 

Title of the reviewed article:

 

Reviewer:

 

Review deadline:

 

* Please underline the statement that corresponds entirely to your opinion of the reviewed work.

 

1. The paper complies with the scope of the journal Bulgarian Folklore:

fully

to some extent

does not

 

2. The paper deals with a major scientific problem:

fully

to some extent

does not

 

3. The author is well familiar with the state of art in the respective research field and the literature related:

yes

relatively

scarcely

 

4. The article has merit to the research field:

significant

some

no

 

5. The paper has merits to (You are allowed to chose more than one answer):

theory of the

problems discussed

enriches the respective research

field in interpretation and new data

presents new materials from filed research

 

6. The authors aims, statements and conclusion are formulated and presented in the article:

 

clearly and well

relatively well

poorly

 

7. The presentation is consistent, logical and gives good arguments in support of the thesa advocated:

yes

to some extent

no of the above

 

8. The article is comprehensible, legible and its style and language are at:

high level

relatively good level

low level

 

9. The abstract and the key words reveal truly and completely the content of article:

 

yes

to some extent

do not

 

10. Comments and recommendations to be taken into account by the author:

 

11. You suggest that the Editorial Board should:

publish the article without

any changes

 

 

publish the article after a revision

reject the article

 

 

DATE: